Whether you are a Buyer or a Seller, a CMA is something you should review with a critical eye.
CMA can mean "Comparative Market Analysis" or "Competitive Market Analysis." Just depends on who you ask. Either way, it is designed to help you with determining the price at which you should list your home (Seller) or with determining whether the list price on a property you want to buy is appropriate (Buyer). It works equally for both parties in the transaction. This is why it is critical that your agent be skilled at devising a CMA for you.
A CMA uses recent sales as its base. If there are enough, at least 3-4 properties that are similar to the "Subject" property should be used. Hopefully, these have sold within the past 6 months. Ideally, they would be within 200 square feet in size, within 2 years in age, and are preferably in the exact same neighborhood. I have seen the exact same floor plan by the exact same builder in Pflugerville sell for $185,000 when it is selling for $219,000 in southwest Austin.
Ask your agent how the CMA s/he is presenting to you was figured mathematically. If the answer is related to simply determining an average dollar per square foot based on properties that were sold in the neighborhood in the past six months, BE WARY!! We don't have the luxury of viewing the properties that have been sold. We do have descriptions, however, that would likely include selling points such as granite countertops, wood flooring, sprinkler systems, etc. A property with granite, wood, travertine, and other recent improvements that might include a new HVAC system or water heater or range, is going to have a higher value than one with its original formica, carpet, sheet vinyl, and mechanicals. There could be as much as a $20,000-$30,000 difference in market value for the exact same floor plan!! Adjustments have to be based on things like this as well as location. Does the property back to a busy road? Does it back to a dedicated greenbelt? There is going to be a value difference even if everything else is exactly the same!
Bottom line here: Review a CMA with a critical eye and ask questions. A good CMA can be the difference between listing your home for sale at the wrong price or listing it at a fair market value. A good CMA can be the difference between paying too much for your home or paying a fair market value. It is important to both sides to reach agreement at a fair price.
Wednesday, July 2, 2008
CMA? What's That?
Tuesday, June 17, 2008
Choose Your Lender Carefully!!
I was concerned I would not have enough to discuss when I started this Blog venture. I don't know why. Seems nearly every transaction reminds me of something to share with you!
Choose your lender carefully. Seems obvious but I'm betting you are thinking you should be looking for the best interest rate. While that should be part of your lender selection criteria, let me just suggest you also make it a point to find someone LOCAL to work with. In fact, ask your loan officer (whoever it is and whatever institution s/he is with) if s/he plans to attend your closing!! Doesn't seem important now. Definitely could be later.
Here is what happened. Everything was pretty smooth. Lender was slow in getting closing documents to the title company. A little nerve-wracking but they finally make it (about one hour before the Seller is scheduled to sign). Closer works really hard and gets a final, approved HUD (Settlement Statement). Closer gets Seller to sign off. The Buyers and I arrive at the title company for our appointment at 2:00 p.m. Everything goes swimmingly! It seems so easy! The closer faxes the documents required by the lender for review in order for them to go ahead and release funds.
Lender says it won't fund until it receives the pest inspection report!!!! WHAT pest inspection report?!?!?!? Was never a condition received by the loan officer or the loan processor. What are you talking about?!?
Bottom line here: The loan officer was AT the closing and immediately took charge. He and the processor were in direct communication with the lender for nearly 2 hours to get this situation resolved. After communicating that this condition had never been provided to the loan officer or the processor or the Buyers, the lender eventually waived the condition (a rare occurrence!) and allowed funding to take place.
If the loan officer had not been there, we would not have been able to get funded that day. In fact, we probably would have felt compelled to get a pest inspection report ASAP. Remember, your Realtor does not have any loan information and is not involved in the loan process. We can't fight any battles with the lender. The loan officer can. Now you can see why it is really important to have someone LOCAL working (and sometimes fighting!) for you. Just my suggestion.
Monday, June 9, 2008
How to Buy a House
Sounds pretty basic, doesn't it? Buy a house. Can't be that hard!
Steps:
1) Decide if resale or brand new and narrow down the area of interest.
2) Talk to Realtor.
3) Talk to Lender.
4) Review listings and/or new community web sites provided by Realtor.
5) Narrow potential properties and go visit them with Realtor.
6) Decide on property and have Realtor run Comparative Market Analysis for pricing info.
7) Work through Offer with Realtor to submit to Seller/Seller's Realtor.
8) Negotiate until reach contract.
9) Complete inspections during Option Period.
10) Re-negotiate any inspection items.
11) Finalize necessary paperwork with Lender.
12) Get utilities turned on for your closing date.
13) Close!!!
There is more detail for some of these steps on my 5/5/2008 blog. The takeaways for you from this blog is to contact your Realtor even if you are thinking about buying a brand new home and to consider buying if your credit score and your income stream are good.
Most home builders are perfectly happy to see you arrive with your Realtor. That means they won't have to do nearly as much work! They will leave the education part of the transaction up to your agent and go on about selling to folks who arrive without a Realtor. Oh... and those new home prices? They are just as negotiable, if not more so, than resale prices.
So... don't wait around waiting to "time the (housing) market." You can't do that any better than timing the stock market. BUT... with interest rates still historically low and many more motivated Sellers (including those new home builders), this is a good time to think about buying a home. Good credit? Fairly secure in your income? Think about it.
Tuesday, June 3, 2008
Inspections - What they are... and what they are not
My story. A few years ago, I flew to my Louisiana hometown to retrieve a 1991 GMC Sierra Z71 pickup truck with 29,000 original miles on it as a surprise for my stepson (who didn't have his license yet but would soon). The truck had belonged to my cousin. I asked my aunt to have it fully checked out by the local Chevrolet dealership. I spent $1,400 getting hoses and belts replaced, etc., etc., etc. I set out on my 6-hour road trip back to Texas confident there would be no problems on the road. Four hours in, as I approached Bryan-College Station, the truck died. Yep. There I sat. A tow into Pete's Exxon (I LOVE those guys!) revealed a fuel pump gone bad. Four hours later, I was BACK on the road for the remaining 2 hours of my journey, about $300 poorer but just happy to be going home.
Okay. The point is that any inspection is a snapshot in time. It does not guarantee that something working at that moment will work tomorrow... or a month later... or a year later. Frequently a Buyer (or Seller who has a pre-inspection done) will be absolutely infuriated when the air conditioner or dishwasher goes out several weeks after the closing.
What good is the inspection? Well, it provides you with information on the mechanical systems and visible structural condition of a property. It lets you know which wall outlets are working and which aren't. It lets you know that the oven is actually baking at 360 degrees when you have it set at 350 degrees. It lets you know if all of the faucets will run water and all of the water closets will flush. It lets you know if the roof is nearly new or if it is as old as the 25-year old house you are buying. It lets you know the manufacturer, age, and condition (in the inspector's opinion) of the HVAC unit, the water heater, the dishwasher, and so on. It lets you know if the attic could use another 3 inches of insulation. It gives you a snapshot in time of the condition (working v. not working) of most of the critical items of the property. It is intended to provide you with an idea of what you might expect from those critical items in the future.
What the inspection will NOT do is tell you what will happen to any or all of those items in the future. None of us have 20/20 foresight. The inspector is doing the best he or she can to note every little thing that is noticed during this 2-3 hour process. An inspector does not have a crystal ball.
So... don't shoot the messenger. Thank the inspector for crawling around in the attic in mid-August in Central Texas. Thank the inspector for not only showing up but for the time he or she will be spending creating the inspection report. Thank the inspector for checking out items (and giving an opinion) you don't know anything about!! The inspector is actually one of your very best friends in this whole transaction.
Tuesday, May 27, 2008
Contractual Obligation v. Reality
Well, yet another unfortunate circumstance has come to my attention based on a recent transaction. I sure hate dealing with these but it does provide fodder for me to provide information to you in hopes you won't make the same misstep. If nothing else, hopefully you will be a little more educated.
After the mechanical inspection on a property my Buyers had a contract on, we submitted a Repair Amendment that clearly outlined what was required by the Sellers to address the concerns raised by the inspection. The Sellers agreed to nearly all of the requested repairs as well as the clearly written language that "licensed professional" vendors were to be used for some of them (HVAC, Electrical, etc.) and that receipts from same would be provided to us one week prior to closing. ALL parties (Buyers and Sellers) signed off on the final agreed Amendment.
Closing was delayed due to lender issues but did finally occur 5 days late. The promised receipts had never been provided. There were a number of major issues going on including a Buyer moving from California with no place else to go but the property! My Buyers needed to get this deal closed and move on.
The repair receipts were never provided. About two weeks after closing, I requested them from the Listing Agent on the deal. A week later, I requested a response to my request. I received an acknowledgement that the collection of the receipts was underway. Today marks another week passed and I have sent yet another request. This one was unfortunately prompted by my Buyers' need for the Residential Service Contract provider to be contacted due to the air conditioning failure last Thursday, 5/22. The HVAC service technician made a couple of interesting notes about the problem. The new neighbor also commented that the Sellers had not been able to get the HVAC working when they were there "refurbishing" the property. They apparently brought portable cooling equipment to work.
What's my point? The Sellers had a contractual obligation to do what they agreed to do when they signed off on the final Repair Amendment. They did not do so. What options did we have along the way? We could have pressed harder for the receipts. They were not forthcoming. We could have refused to close... but where would my Buyer be with a van load of furnishings arriving? The reality is the deal is done. The reality is there was nothing to do short of calling breach of contract when the receipts were not made available. Oh... did I mention closing was pushed back 5 days? Yep. That technically put us in breach. The Sellers probably didn't want to call it since they would have had to start all over again to sell their property.
The lesson here is to determine in advance exactly what you are willing to "let slide" v. exactly what you are going to hold the other party to before agreeing to close. If the issue is not critical to you, be ready to let it go. If it IS critical... make certain the other party upholds what they agreed to do to remedy the situation. Once that horse is out of the barn, it's pretty hard to get it back in. Once you close, there isn't much left for you to do about what did or did not occur. The contract is considered to have been fulfilled with agreement by all parties.
Friday, May 16, 2008
Affordability v. Energy Efficiency?
There has been a lot of "discussion" lately regarding the "Climate Protection Plan" introduced by Mayor Will Wynn in 2007. There are advocates on both sides of the fence. Understand that absoutely nothing is solidly in place at this writing and that final decisions have yet to be made.
At issue is the possibility that specific repairs/replacements would have to be done and approved by the city before a homeowner could sell his or her existing home. These repairs/replacements would be intended to increase the energy efficiency of the home.
Opponents of this have put together advertising campaigns to warn Austin homeowners of what may lie ahead. You can read a lot of information about how this came about and what has taken place thus far at KeepAustinAffordable.org. It also has a blog feature that will allow you to follow what will happen in the future. I suggest you subscribe to it if you are a homeowner or if you are considering becoming one.
On the other hand, like many government initiatives, I personally believe the road leading to this is paved with good intentions. I think most of us would like to achieve the best level of energy efficiency we possibly can. The problem is how our local government is considering implementation and the possibility that, if allowed to put this into place, more initiatives are likely in the name of "energy efficiency."
My bottom line? Let's just start with the fact I do NOT like the government to put itself in a position to tell me what I must do with my personal property. I do not believe it has that right and I will fight to keep what I believe to be my right to maintain my home in the manner I see fit... and can afford. If we allow the city of Austin to tell us what must be done to our homes before we can sell them, what will they tell us next? Will we have to convert our existing automobile to a hybrid status before it can be sold? Don't laugh.
Just check out the facts. There is plenty of available information out there. Whichever side of that fence you are on, remember that you need to make your voice heard. Of course, with the dismal turnout for Austin elections evidenced recently, perhaps you prefer that others make decisions for you? I certainly hope not.
Monday, May 5, 2008
Ready to Buy???
Alright! You are ready to take that next step. Whether you are buying your very first home or whether you are moving up to the 5th or 6th of 7th home... there are things you need to do before you begin viewing properties and definitely before you sign paperwork.
First-time Home Buyers. It is important for you to do a couple of things right up front. First, find yourself a good real estate agent. Sure, I'm happy to help you but ask your family, friends, and co-workers if they have a recommendation for you. Someone will have used an agent in the past they just loved working with. (You might also find out who to avoid!) However you decide to find an agent, find one, interview him or her, then either commit to working with that individual (if you feel comfortable with that person) or find another agent and interview that party. Keep doing this until you are comfortable with the individual you decide on. You are going to be spending a LOT of time with him or her in the near future! Secondly, use the same process to find a loan officer. Ask your chosen agent to recommend a couple that he or she has worked with successfully in the past. Ask those same family, friends, and co-workers for suggestions. You probably only need to do a phone interview with the two or three you decide to interview. But make sure you are comfortable with this party, also. You are going to be sharing a LOT of personal information about your finances with him or her!
Multiple-time Home Buyers. Yep. You have done this before. You know the drill. Get in touch with the agent you liked from a previous transaction. Get in touch with the loan officer you liked. And, hey!! If you weren't too thrilled with someone in the past, check with your family, friends, and co-workers for other potential agents and/or loan officers.
Everyone! Just like the "Ready to Sell?" checklist, there is one that applies to those in the "Ready to Buy?" category. In no particular order:
Define the area you are interested in. This might be based on your job location, the schools serving an area, proximity to the lake... whatever YOU decide it is based on. I don't care. But as an agent, I do need to know!
Decide on your price range... and STICK TO IT! When you chat with your loan officer, he or she will be able to give you a general idea of what your payments will be within a given price range. I don't care if you qualify for a $1 Million loan!! If you don't want payments over $1,300 each month, that will define the price range you need to be looking in. I need to know this, too!
Make a list of "must-haves" and a separate list of "wants." We can find a 3 bedroom, 2 bath home with a 2-car attached garage nearly anywhere in nearly any price range. If your "must-have" list has too many specific items on it, we aren't going to see a lot of properties that fit your criteria. Keep the "must-haves" to the bare minimum... location (area), # of bedrooms, # of bathrooms, price-range, one-story or two-story. Let the "wants" list guide you as you view properties to help you narrow your list to 2 or 3 to truly consider.
Finally, enjoy the process. It should not be a chore. It should be fun. I always start a viewing appointment with a coffee/tea purchase for me and for my clients. It provides a "beginning" to the process. Kind of gets everyone in the mood to go house-shopping!
There is a lot more I will be sharing about both the Selling and the Buying process in future blogs. The first steps are covered now. Stay tuned!